In the world of real estate, some properties move with the speed of a 98-mph fastball. That was certainly the case recently in the prestigious Arches section of Old Westbury, where former New York Mets star outfielder Brandon Nimmo officially closed the chapter on his Long Island residency. 

Represented by Scott Van Son and Stephen Gevinski of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Laffey International Realty, Nimmo’s sophisticated Hamptons-style ranch at 3 Horseshoe Road sold for $5,695,000. The home generated such buzz when it came to market, Van Son and Gevinski were fielding offers and entering negotiations within less than 48 hours of it going live.

How it came to be

Representing a high-profile athlete requires discretion, credibility, and a strong approach to marketing. "We were brought into this project through a referral from Brandon’s financial team," said listing agent Van Son. "Even with that connection, the selection process was incredibly competitive. We ultimately beat out several other top brokers and representatives to secure the opportunity to represent this estate."

The decision to trust Van Son and Gevinski paid off. While Nimmo was traded to the Texas Rangers in November 2025, he waited until April to officially list the property, and the market response was instantaneous. "Our success was a result of a highly coordinated Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Laffey International Realty strategy," Gevinski explained. "From our digital presence and market 'splashes' to the meticulous editing of our photography and video, every detail was designed to trigger an immediate reaction. When you combine that level of marketing with a truly unique property, the market responds instantly."

A rare find on the North Shore

What does nearly $5.7 million buy in Old Westbury? For Nimmo, who purchased the home in 2023 for $5 million (notably paying $200,000 over the asking price at the time), the property was a rare find. 

The home’s ranch design is a significant part of its appeal. Spanning 5,200 square feet, the residence is an uncommon yet desirable gem in a region known for different architectural traditions. "On Long Island, the architectural landscape is dominated by the traditional Colonial. A ranch of this caliber is an anomaly here," said Van Son. "It stands out because it offers a different kind of horizontal elegance and ease of living that you just don't find in the more common local styles."

A home run home

The property is divided into distinct wings. The "work wing" includes a private office equipped with a full bath, allowing it to easily serve as a fifth bedroom for guests or extended family. The private bedroom wing is separated from the work and entertaining spaces by a dramatic living room with cathedral ceilings and a gas fireplace. 

When asked which features captured the hearts of potential buyers, Van Son noted that the scale of the private quarters was a major selling point. "The primary bedroom is the soul of the house; the vaulted ceilings are massive and create an incredible sense of volume," he said. "Beyond that, the dual living rooms offer a sophisticated flow, but ultimately, the architecture of the ranch speaks for itself." Additional highlights include generous storage space, a dedicated laundry area, and a three-car garage featuring the vertical clearance necessary for car lifts—a dream for a serious collector.

The expansive eat-in kitchen is another home run. It features top-tier refrigeration and cooking appliances, centered around a large island. Interestingly, the home was sold turnkey, with all furnishings and personal property included. "The fact that the home was offered fully furnished—selling exactly as it was originally purchased—added immense appeal," Van Son added.

For Gevinski, the home’s standout feature is clear. “The backyard is my favorite place in the home. It’s like a country club—the pool reminds me of one you’d find at a 5-star resort.” To ensure the home functions as well as it looks, a convenient side entrance off the pool leads directly to a full bath—a thoughtful touch that allows guests to refresh without tracking through the main living areas.

Brandon Nimmo’s departure from Long Island marks the end of an era for Mets fans who grew to love his hustle on the field. As he has already headed to the Lone Star State to suit up for the Rangers, he leaves behind one of the most successful residential transactions in Old Westbury this year.